Hattie McDaniel was the first Black Oscar winner. It didn't help her … – The Washington Post

clockThis article was published more than 1 year ago
A previous version of this article misstated the name of the author of “Gone With the Wind.” She is Margaret Mitchell, not Martha. The article has been corrected.
On the evening of Feb. 29, 1940, actress Hattie McDaniel, with white gardenias in her hair, swept into the Ambassador Hotel’s Cocoanut Grove nightclub in Los Angeles for the Academy Awards banquet. That night, she would become the first African American ever to win an Oscar for her role as an enslaved maid in the blockbuster movie “Gone With the Wind.”
But the hotel didn’t allow the 44-year-old McDaniel to sit at the same table as the film’s White cast members. And her historic award for best supporting actress didn’t open doors to better movie roles for Black actors, including McDaniel herself. Instead of winning wider success because of her Oscar, she said later, “it was if I had done something wrong.”
An African American didn’t win a competitive Oscar again until 1964 (James Baskett won an honorary Oscar in 1948 for portraying Uncle Remus), when the best actor award went to Sidney Poitier, who died this year at age 94. It wasn’t until 2002 that Halle Berry became the only African American to win the best actress award.
African Americans have won 20 acting Oscars, but as recently as 2015, a call for more diversity began under the banner #OscarsSoWhite. This year, four African Americans are nominated for acting awards, down from nine last year, at Sunday’s ceremony at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood.
Sidney Poitier acted his way out of a brutal introduction to America
McDaniel’s rise from poverty to an Academy Award is a story right out of the movies. She grew up in Colorado as the youngest of 13 children. Both her parents had been enslaved; her father was a Baptist minister. She performed in Black minstrel shows before moving to Los Angeles, where she eventually built a movie career in comedies as a sassy maid.
In 1939, a huge opportunity arose. Producer David O. Selznick bought the rights to Margaret Mitchell’s best-selling book “Gone With the Wind,” about the Old South before and after the Civil War. The heavyset McDaniel, who worked as a maid between acting jobs, won the part of the family maid Mammy at the Tara plantation.
Selznick cast British actress Vivien Leigh as Southern belle Scarlett O’Hara and matinee idol Clark Gable as Scarlett’s suitor, Rhett Butler.
The producer faced criticism from the NAACP and Black newspapers over the racism in Mitchell’s book, which romanticizes slavery.
Earl Morris of the Pittsburgh Courier, a Black newspaper, predicted that “Gone With the Wind” would be even more racist than the movie “The Birth of a Nation.” Selznick studio officials responded to Morris, telling him that the n-word had been deleted from the movie’s script and agreeing to exclude the book’s references to the Ku Klux Klan.
The film premiered in racially segregated Atlanta on Dec. 15, 1939. An estimated 300,000 people lined the street to see the movie’s stars in a parade. Guests at the Loews Grand Theater included elderly Confederate War veterans. Also performing was a choir of African American children, including 10-year-old Martin Luther King Jr.
When the nearly four-hour movie ended, Atlanta Mayor William Hartsfield spoke. “His voice shook as he called upon the members of the cast and thanked them,” the New York Times reported. “He asked the audience to applaud the Negro members of the cast, none of whom was present.” McDaniel had declined to attend because she couldn’t sit in the theater or stay at the same hotels as White cast members.
The Chicago Defender, a Black newspaper, called the movie a “weapon of terror against Black America.” Most newspapers gave the film rave reviews, and many singled out McDaniel for praise. “No one who sees the picture can ever forget her,” the Atlanta Constitution reviewer wrote. “In fact, she stole the show quite frequently.”
In early 1940, McDaniel was nominated for an Oscar. She attended the awards ceremony as a special guest of Selznick because the Ambassador Hotel didn’t typically allow African Americans. She and her escort, Black actor Ferdinand Yober, and her White agent sat at a small table at the back of the ballroom, behind a long table for the movie’s White cast members.
The ceremony, like current ones, dragged into the night. Columnist Harold Heffernan described what happened next: “It was 12:50 a.m.— nearly five hours after the starting bell — before the twelfth annual Academy Awards dinner managed to whip up a flicker of excitement. Then — with only a pair of statues to best supporting actor and actress left — the drooping dinner came to life.”
Actress Fay Bainter announced the award for best supporting actress. “Spectators stifled their yawns and leaned forward expectantly — then gasped. … For Miss Bainter had called for Hattie McDaniel” to receive the award, the columnist wrote. “There was silence for several moments, and then the tumult got under way. … The crowd was tendering an ovation never paralleled in Academy history.”
Meet the Black hairstylists making history at the Oscars this year
McDaniel gave a short and emotional acceptance speech. “I sincerely hope that I shall always be a credit to my race and the motion picture industry,” she concluded, and left the stage in tears. “Gone With the Wind” won eight of the 20 awards, including best picture and best actress.
Hollywood columnist Louella Parsons hailed McDaniel’s award as a breakthrough showing “race or color must not interfere where credit is due.” Columnist Jimmie Fidler took a different view: “And where does this Negro artist go from here? Why back to playing incidental comedy maids, of course. I don’t think it will be easy for me to laugh at Hattie’s comedy in the future.”
Fidler was right. McDaniel continued to be offered roles mainly as maids and cooks. The NAACP’s executive director, Walter White, singled her out in criticizing Black actors playing subservient and stereotypical parts. McDaniel responded, “I would rather make $700 a week playing a maid than $7 being one.”
In 1947, McDaniel landed the title role of the popular national radio program “The Beulah Show,” again portraying a comic maid. A few years later, she was diagnosed with breast cancer. She died in 1952 at age 57.
The actress faced racism even in death. She had asked to be buried in Hollywood Cemetery, but the cemetery was closed to African Americans. In October 1952, 3,000 people attended McDaniel’s funeral in Los Angeles. “After the funeral services, 125 limousines formed a procession to Rosedale Cemetery, where she was buried,” the New York Times reported.
When McDaniel died, her estate was valued at about $10,000, equal to $106,000 now. Most of it went to paying back taxes. She willed $1 to one of her four ex-husbands. She bequeathed her Oscar to Howard University in Washington, D.C., but it has been lost.
In recent years, “Gone With the Wind” has faced a backlash because of its racism, but adjusted for inflation it is still the highest-grossing film ever. McDaniel’s reputation has risen as a Black movie pioneer who had little power to choose her roles.
In 2010, when Black actress Mo’Nique accepted the Oscar for best supporting actress for her role in “Precious,” she wore white gardenias, as McDaniel had 70 years before. “I want to thank Miss Hattie McDaniel,” Mo’Nique said, “for enduring all she had to, so I would not have to.”